It is remarkable how often one sees the name Robert Schiller in the mainstream media these days. It is as if the prophet has come back from the wilderness. Back in 2000, he justifiably made his reputation as the man who predicted the collapse of the dot.com bubble. However, when he turned his sights on the housing market, people just didn't want to hear from him. People were too busy counting up the so-called equity accumulating in their homes, and his message of serious overvaluation and speculative behaviour was most unwelcome.
Today, he gave an interview, and made some obvious points about the real estate market. For example, he observes that if house prices are increasing 10 percent a year, then fairly soon no one can afford one. Perhaps more shockingly, he points out that over the long-term the return from owning a house is fairly close to zero.
Question: What caused the stock bubble, and why did it end as it did?
Answer: Some sociologists talk about collective consciousness. We humans evolved to be very closely linked, and our minds focus on the same ideas. Those [ideas] get reinforced because we hear them all the time.
Back in the late 1990s, you kept hearing that you had to stake your claim on the Internet or you'd miss out on the future. No one cared about the present. Then something happened around March 2000. There was an acceleration of public talk about doubts. You could no longer declare at a cocktail party that Internet stocks were going up. Such statements had become embarrassing - and just like that, word of mouth changed.
Embarrassment is a powerful emotion.
Question: Is that about to happen in real estate?
Answer: It doesn't seem like we're there quite yet. But this is the biggest boom in housing prices since, well, ever. Nothing seems to explain it, and nobody forecast it. It seems to me...wait a minute. Please don't quote me as forecasting the markets.
Question: Okay. What you're about to say is not a forecast.
Answer: Well, human thinking is built around stories, and the story that has sustained the housing boom is that homes are like stocks. Buy one anywhere and it'll go up. It's the easiest way to get rich.
Question: So how rich can you get on real estate?
Answer: From 1890 through 1990, the return on residential real estate was just about zero after inflation.
Question: Excuse me? That's all? Hasn't it been higher lately?
Answer: Since 1987 it's been 6 percent [or about 3 percent a year after inflation].
Question: So real estate doesn't go up roughly 10 percent a year?
Answer: It can't be true that homes rise 10 percent a year. If they did, in the long run no one would be able to afford a house.
Question: Let me grab a calculator. If real estate really rose 10 percent a year, a $25,000 home in 1957 should be worth roughly $3 million now.
Answer: And that flies in the face of common sense. In fact, I'm inclined to think there's a good chance that the return on real estate will be negative, substantially negative, over the next 10 years because all booms reverse in the end.
Question: All right. We won't call that a forecast either. So how should people think about their home as an asset?
Answer: Avoid concentration of risks. You need a house, but I would avoid a second one - or at least avoid an outsize house. Over-investing in real estate now would be a recipe for disaster.
Question: You also write about the risk to human capital. What's that?
Answer: What you're trying to do is to invest in skills that somebody else will want to pay you for. Let's say you want to work at Bethlehem Steel. That would have been a good idea in the 1950s, not so good by the 1970s. The world went the wrong way on you.
Question: How can you manage that risk?
Answer: I used to coach children's soccer, and I would tell my players, "Stand away from the pack, and sooner or later the ball will come to you."
In your career choices too: Get away from the pack. Also, you associate your home country with safety. But the rest of the world is pretty peaceful too, on average, and the average is all that matters.
I think relatively few [Americans] are getting away from the pack, investing more outside the U.S. than in.
Question: How are you investing now?
Answer: I'm probably a little over 60 percent in stocks, almost all of it outside the U.S. I have a lot of cash. And I've been reducing my exposure to real estate. It may be at the end of a cycle.
It is one of the great mysteries of the modern age; why was so much of this housing bubble so obvious, so predictable, and yet so difficult to avoid. It is a comparatively simple matter to examine housing data and see prices diverging systematically from long-run trends. It is also straightforward to look at house price to income ratios and see that housing had become unaffordable for all but the most affluent. Yet despite these obvious indicators, Americans chose to ignore the obvious and instead believe the unbelievable; namely, that house prices could continue to grow in excess of 20 percent a year.
This mystery is all the more difficult to understand given the experiences of the stock market in the late 1990s. The parallels between the dot.com bubble and the recent housing fiasco are almost too obvious to highlight. However, given the widespread desire within society to believe the unbelievable, it is sadly necessary to state the obvious. In both bubbles, people were being asked to believe that economic fundamentals were no longer important; that there was something different this time, and that conventional ways of doing things were suddenly redundant.
However, ordinary homebuyers were not the only group to fail to see that the housing market was degenerating into a speculative mess. Journalists, particularly those working on local and regional newspapers, were also susceptible. No doubt, many journalists owned modest properties, and were elated when property prices started to rise. They wanted to believe, like so many property owners, that getting rich was merely a matter of holding on to an asset and waiting for it to appreciate. Given this strong desire to see prices rise, journalists often blinded themselves to obvious indicators of property overvaluation.
Wishful thinking can never overcome the realities of supply and demand. As sure as night follows day, the housing bubble popped, prices began to sink, and elation was followed with despair. Today, we are increasingly seeing newspaper headlines that should have been published five years ago.
Consider, for example, today's headline in the Washington Post "Housing boom tied to sham mortgages". The article recounts the activities of Phillip Hill, who "lured people to fancy cocktail parties in a $1.9 million mansion. He asked to use their names and credit histories in real estate deals, promising to make them rich. Most got $10,000 checks on the spot for signing up. By the time the scam unraveled, the credit of those participants had been ruined, hundreds of upscale properties had fallen into foreclosure and real estate prices had plummeted in some of this city's most exclusive neighborhoods. Hill is about to go to federal prison".
However, the article also points out that since 2000 mortgage related fraud has increased tenfold. Let us consider that statistic, it saying that mortgage fraud increased by 1000 percent in seven years. The growth in mortgage fraud makes the housing bubble look like a blip on the chart. So how is it that journalists failed to notice this explosion in housing-related crime? Why weren't they exposing the activities of people like Phillip hill back in 2002?
The answer is straightforward enough. They were too busy writing feelgood stories about the Washington real estate market. Rather than doing their jobs, they wanted to believe the unbelievable, ignore the obvious, and as a consequence failed to report the truth.
Mortgage lenders are falling like flies. Today, it was the turn of American Home Mortgage Investment to tell its investors about the sorry state of the US housing market. The company slashed its dividend and 2007 profit forecasts. Several analysts quickly responded to the dismal news and downgraded its stock. Subsequently, the share price sank as much as 18.2 percent.
The company cited a lack of buyers for its loans, as well as rising delinquencies, for its lowered forecast. It joined M&T Bank among lenders to cut profit forecasts. Moreover, there are increasing signs that weakness afflicting sub prime mortgages may be spreading to higher-quality loans. American Home specializes in prime and near-prime loans and makes roughly 2.5 percent of all U.S. mortgages.
The disease that nearly destroyed the sub prime market is now spreading to the prime and near prime mortgage market. According to FirstAmerican LoanPerformance, In February, 2.6 percent of Alt-A loans were delinquent by 60 or more days, up from 1.2 percent a year before.
Just wait, soon we will see stories about higher delinquencies among prime mortgage lenders.
House auctions are becoming the preferred way for mortgage lenders to quickly dump unwanted properties. In Colorado, it is boomtime for the foreclosure business. According to Realtytrac, in February, the state suffered one foreclosure filing for every 345 households, making the state's foreclosure rate the second highest in the nation. In February alone, Colorado reported a total of 5,310 foreclosures.
All properties available on April 21st are sold "as is". Interested buyers are encouraged not to bid on any home they haven't seen. Buyers can view an entire list of properties online at http://www.hudsonandmarshall.com/
Some people think that realtors are a parasitical profession. For just posting an advert on the MLS system and showing some suckers around an overpriced house, they demand a six percent cut of the selling price.
For those who find the realtor exams a little tough, there is a new profession for wannabe parasites - a home staging consultant. House sellers call these jokers in when the house is stuck on the market. For a fat fee, these "consultants" come to your house and tell you to tidy the place up before the house buying sucker comes to visit.
In order to qualify as a Home Staging Consultant - you will need to take a "30 hour intensive immersion course". This program is "jam packed with practical ideas and sound business practices honed by years of working in the field". There is also an organisation that can rip you off with membership fees - the Certified Staging Professional.
The emergence of this new "profession" with their "intensive training programs" is yet another sign that the market is in trouble. Does anyone remember a time when a crappy slumhouse would go on the market on a Friday, have an open house on s Sunday and sold on a Monday. The breakfast dishes were still in the sink; the beds weren't made and the house was still holding the a strong body odour of the hygiene-challenged owners. That sort of thing was common two years ago. Today, that kind of house just doesn't get a visit.
So along comes the house stagers. These consultants are there to help sustain the denial. "It is not about the price, it is about the dirty laundry under the bed". For those desperate to sell, avoid the homestagers. Reconsider the price. If it ain't selling, it is over priced. Cut, cut and cut again. Eventually, there will be a buyer out there for your house.
The delivery of this video clip is definitely wierd. However, the commentary is compelling.
In this particular video, Strange Gordon slams London as being the international center for money laundering. Of course, the London housing market is in on the scam. The message is clear; if you have the cash, London loves ya.
Gordon finishes the video with a bombshell factiod. Although London has some very tough anti-money laundering legislation, there has not been a single prosecution of a UK banker for handling dodgy money. Given that one in five house purchases over $1 million is bought by a Russian, this beggers belief.
So there you have it. London isn't just the most bubblicious city in the world. It is the money laundering center of choice for the world's criminals.
This is the only chart you will ever need for the US housing market. It is the famous Shiller chart, from the man you brought you Irrational Exuberance.
The chart is simple enough. It plots two long term series; real house prices adjusted for inflation and real rents adjusted for inflation. It make two simple points. First, in the last 100 or so years, US house prices, in real terms, have never been higher. Second, renting a house, in inflation adjusted terms, is close to its all time low.
Print the chart out. Put it in your wallet or stick it in your purse. Everytime you hear someone talking about real estate, pull it out and just show them the chart and say just one short sentence comprising of 20 brutal but truthful words.
"In the last century, it has never been more expensive to buy house or more cheaper to rent than today."
Check out this great post by Brad Setser. He examines what he calls three "dated perceptions of China", namely:
1. Crappy banks - Chinese state owned banks are filled with non-performing loans,
2. Externally balanced trade - China runs a surplus with the US but a deficit with the rest of the world, so its trade is in rough balance and finally that
3. A technologically deficient economy - China just assembles imported components with little value-added.
Not so, says Brad. Time to correct those outdated ideas about China.
Labels:

Japan is holding a mountain of US dollars. The Finance Minstry in Tokyo reported that Japan's foreign exchange reserves rose to an all-time high of 908.96 billion dollars at the end of March from the previous record of 905.05 billion dollars in February. Japan's large foreign exchange reserves are the result of years of currency intervention by the government to keep the yen down against the dollar and help exporters stay competitive. In other words, the Japanese have kept the Yen artiificially low so that they could flood US markets with cheap goods.
However, the Japanese are not the only ones playing this game. Japan’s foreign exchange reserves are the second largest in the world, after China, whose holdings reached 1.07 trillion dollars at the end of 2006.

A day does not pass without more news about the US housing market. Today, it was the turn of the Mortgage Bankers Association to supply the doom and gloom. Loan applicationss are down.Their seasonally adjusted index of mortgage applications fell for the third straight week, dropping 3.2% to 649.5 in the week ended March 30. The MBA's seasonally adjusted purchase index declined 2.0% to 402.9, while its refinancing applications index fell 4.5% to 2,098.3.
There was further bad news on interest rates. Borrowing costs rose for all loan types. The average 30-year fixed-rate mortgage, excluding fees, rose 0.09 percentage point from the prior week to 6.13 percent.

1