Today's housing market problems gave plenty of warning. Since the summer of 2005, real estate indicators everywhere had been flashing red. Inventory, sales, new home incentives were all telling the same story. The market had peaked and it was going to crash.
For example, take a look at just one indicator - KB homes, and in particular, its share price. In early summer 2005, the stock was trading at around $84; three months later it was down at $66. Although there was a temporary rebound during the winter of 2005, thereafter it has traded at around half of what it was during those heady days of summer.
Back then, smart investors knew that the housing bubble was over. Prices were just too far out of whack with reality. The KB homes share price reflected that unsustainability. Since everyone with an Internet connection had access to KBH data, it should not have been too difficult to see where things were going.
Of course, it did not quite happen that way. People looked at the rising housing inventory, declining sales and rising interest rates and somehow could not bring themselves to admit that the market had topped out. Denial and delusion are essential ingredients to any financial catastrophe, and America had both in abundance.
Up until a few weeks ago, many people still believed that the housing slowdown was only temporary. It has taken a 5 percent mortgage delinquency rate and the disappearance of 40 or so sub prime lenders before America as a whole woke up and understand that there was a crisis.
What about KB homes today? What is it telling us about the future for US housing? Well, the recent numbers are grim. The company just reported numbers for the first quarter. Compared to the same period last year, revenues are down 20 percent; net income fell from $173 million to $27.5 million; while orders fell by 12 percent. The only ray of sunshine comes from their cancellation rate, which improved slightly compared to the fourth quarter of last year.
Chief Executive Jeffrey Mezger suggested that "it is hard to predict when the housing markets will stabilize". Perhaps Mezger should try thinking about it a little harder. If he did bother to think, two somewhat related problems would give Mezger sleepless nights. Thinking on a little further, he would understand that the market will not stabilise any time soon.
First, the recent rise in mortgage delinquency and foreclosure rates, will mean distressed sales at knock down prices. In turn, this will undermine KB homes revenue growth potential. Second, the sub prime fiasco will lead to tighter lending standards, drying up housing demand.
KB homes are looking at nasty double-dip; increased supply of unwanted houses, lower demand due to fearful mortgage lenders, this means only one thing, lower sales volumes at lower prices. Since 2005, the share price has implicitly priced in these problems. The share price was flashing red, telling us that the housing bubble is over. Take heed, it is still flashing red today, and it is telling us that the collapse has only just begun.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
Anonymous said...
KBH first-quarter profit dropped 84%.
Those guys are struggling; take over bid anyone?
Anonymous said...
You should have started your chart back in 2002. Then you would have seen a massive run up in the share price. In some respects,KBH is trading in range very similar to where it was back in the early years of this decade.
Anonymous said...
WASHINGTON (MarketWatch) -- For the first time in the nation's history, a significant number of Americans are being threatened with the loss of their home even though they still have a steady, good-paying job.
It's not just an issue for people with poor credit, those with subprime loans. It also affects people with good enough credit to qualify for a prime loan. Known as Alt-A mortgages, these loans were written for 1 in 5 U.S. mortgages and could have a big impact on the economy and on credit markets -- bigger, perhaps, than the effects of the recent shockwaves buffeting the subprime-lender market, economists say.
http://www.marketwatch.com/news/story/lemming-loans-drive-us-economy/story.aspx?guid=%7B1F050B96%2D5BA3%2D494D%2D9D92%2DFB882963206C%7D&dist=TNMostRead
Anonymous said...
Chief Executive Jeffrey Mezger suggested that "it is hard to predict when the housing markets will stabilize". < Perhaps Mezger should try thinking about it a little harder. >
that there is some good writing.
made me blow boogs.
effenheimer said...
The Economist saw this coming in 2003. They wrote a housing article that any one of us could have written in 2006. Like most of us, they had the direction right and the timing wrong.
I don't think any of us expected this to last as long as it has.
AGLOCO LEADER said...
I foresaw this home mortgage crash coming years ago....
UK Home Mortgages Guy
UK Home Mortgages